• Key players go head-to-head absent the Green

• A godsend for airing important local issues

Ballina’s Federal Election candidate forum took an unexpected and distinctly local turn—held not in a town hall or community centre, but in the Limitless Church, located in the airport industrial estate. Despite some early controversy, including the absence of the Green Party candidate, the event unfolded as one of the most respectful and engaging debates of the campaign season.

To the casual observer, the venue could easily be mistaken for a modern sound stage, save for a glowing Bible verse on the wall—“Worship the Lord in the Beauty of Holiness”—and the fact the debate both opened and closed with prayer. The atmosphere, likely influenced by the setting, remained polite and constructive throughout. There were no sniping or personal attacks in this political beauty contest—just considered answers to thoughtful questions.

Around 70 community members attended, many from other local churches, and the conversation ranged far beyond standard talking points. A godsend result; a more nuanced and meaningful exchange, reflective of some of the less-discussed issues concerning the electorate or that take prominence in the national debates. Important issues like support for independent regional schools, the health of our river and the harms to children from gambling and pornography.

Standout Performances and Surprising Moments

Incumbent MP Justine Elliot demonstrated why she has successfully held the seat for over two decades. Representing the Albanese Government, she articulated Labor’s approach to managing cost-of-living pressures—clearly a key concern for the audience. Elliot presented as experienced, energetic, and approachable; she was notably the most sought-after candidate stopped for selfies afterwards.

Kimberley Hone of the Nationals impressed with her clarity and conviction. Her strongest moment came when she spoke passionately about reopening Mt Warning, drawing the night’s loudest applause. While unseating Elliot will be a challenge, Hone showed she’s a future star for the Nats.

Independent candidate Kevin Loughrey stirred emotions in a different way, asserting that climate change was part of a “communist plot.” His remarks drew audible groans—whether in disagreement or discomfort was hard to determine—but his delivery certainly left an impression.

The unexpected standout, however, was Richard Curtin, representing QLD Senator Gerard Rennick’s People’s Party. A self-described non-politician and Irish-born carpenter (“just like Jesus”), Curtin captivated the room with his heartfelt personal story and straightforward advocacy for small government. Despite limited resources, his charm, Irish lilt, and plainspoken honesty earned him admiration. While he has little chance of winning, he could be a serious player when it comes to preferences—ultimately benefiting the Nationals through his how-to-vote recommendations.

A Pivotal Question

One of the most pointed questions came from Reverend Pablo Nunez of Ballina Uniting Church, who asked candidates to outline their stance on homelessness in the region—an issue weighing heavily on the community. Curtin’s response stood out: he called for the continuation of emergency pod villages established after the 2022 floods, arguing passionately that they should remain in place until permanent solutions are found. Afterwards, Rev. Nunez remarked that Curtin gave the most thoughtful and urgent answer of the night.

What Comes Next?

With election analysts predicting strong performances from independents and minor parties, the ability of minor candidates like Curtin to gather preferences and direct them effectively could shape the final outcome in this 10-horse race—particularly if voters continue their “pox on both your houses” approach to the major parties.

But time is running out, effectively going on hold for the Easter and Anzac holidays. As it stands, betting odds still favour Justine Elliot—Sportsbet lists her at $1.41 to retain the seat—and based on her debate performance, there’s little reason to believe the bookmakers are wrong. But in a campaign where voter sentiment appears more fluid than ever, Ballina’s church debate revealed that, sometimes, the most unconventional settings can offer the clearest insights into the state of politics.

Make up your own mind: The Ballina debate was recorded for later viewing and Ballina News Daily will share the video when it becomes available. Follow us for updates.